Although clinical reasoning abilities are important learning outcomes of physical therapist entry-level education, best practice standards have not been established to guide clinical reasoning curricular design and learning assessment.
This research explored how clinical reasoning is currently defined, taught and assessed in physical therapist entry-level education programs.
A descriptive, cross-sectional survey design was administered to physical therapist program representatives.
An electronic 24-question survey was distributed to Directors of 207 CAPTE-accredited programs. Descriptive statistics and qualitative content analysis were performed. Post-hoc demographic and wave analyses revealed no evidence of non-response bias.
A response rate of 46.4% (n=96) was achieved. All respondents reported incorporating clinical reasoning into their curricula. Only 25% of respondents reported a common definition of clinical reasoning in their program. Most (90.6%) reported clinical reasoning is explicit in their curriculum, with 94.8% using multiple methods of curricular integration. Instructor-designed materials were most commonly used to teach clinical reasoning (83.3%). Clinical reasoning assessment included practical examinations (99%), clinical coursework (94.8%), written examinations (87.5%), and written assignments (83.3%). Curricular integration of clinical reasoning-related self-reflection skills was reported by 91%.
A large number of incomplete surveys affected response rate, and the program directors sent the survey may not have consulted faculty most knowledgeable about clinical reasoning in their curriculum. Survey construction limited some responses and application of results.
While clinical reasoning is explicitly integrated into program curricula, clinical reasoning is not consistently defined, taught, or assessed within or between programs surveyed, resulting in significant variability in clinical reasoning education. These findings support the need for development of best educational practice for clinical reasoning curricula and learning assessment.