Peer 1
Bottom line: High dynamic range = scission and luminance, not just scale normalisation of apparent surface reflectance. Right? And organization matters...
PubPeer
Peer 1
The authors describe this study as having measured “the effect of context on the mapping between luminance and lightness.” This description unacceptably vague, though not uncommon in lightness…
Peer 1
In the ambiguous introduction to their study, the authors state that their stimuli “are missing the geometric factors that, in natural scenes, are associated with a strong impression of different…