@thirdworldq @Rout_PoliticsIR @samhalvorsen @sofiazaragocin @ZenPublisher https://t.co/4VGdUbrI7s I don't know how many takers you'll find given this. Seems like a lot of authors from the Global South (and North) may want to go elsewhere to publish.
@LSEImpactBlog Hm, maybe this post should be amended to note that the article in question was withdrawn due to threats of physical violence. Seems like a noteworthy, sinister part of this story. https://t.co/iO4j5nIpov https://t.co/rnNKDNpLSd
Hoje, relembramos uma polémica no meio académico com a publicação do ensaio “The Case for Colonialism”, de Bruce Gilley, na Third World Quarterly, em 2017. Vejam ou revejam a questão e formem as vossas opiniões. https://t.co/8CfYGwZbEE
@ALanoszka @TobiasBunde Oh yeah,full blown 9/11 conspiracy theories. I remember that too. There was also the controversy that flared at the TWQ (link below). Seems journal arms racing with citations/impact factors is leading editors to accept a lot of absu
Question. How would you cite a retraction notice , considering that it is linked to DOI and therefore retracted paper? Eg https://t.co/OgZOq5go2N
If Bruce Gilley's "The case for colonialism" article has been withdrawn, but his opponent's critical reviews are open for the public, how can we discuss this issue? https://t.co/zuo97VyUiq https://t.co/8m5Obltwip
@BSonblast @Koudoudeh Third World Quarterly published a piece a few years back (though now retracted) saying that colonialism was not that bad: https://t.co/J5ga5WjZ6n
@tandfonline Deeply saddened by your retraction of the article "The case for colonialism" by Bruce Gilley. Threats of violence must never lead to self-censorship of academia! https://t.co/97w6jVt5uS
Basicamente ele defendia que nem todo colonialismo foi "ruim" para o colonizado e que em alguns casos pelo menos foi melhor que não ser. Foi, claro, massacrado e declarado herege total. Aqui o link (acesso pago): https://t.co/PPsmJ9f5fK
@BenBurgis The same guy who published "The case for colonialism" under shady circumstances. https://t.co/3wpxnPBTso
@ideatingenergy @PriyamvadaGopal There was also a controversial article in the Third World Quarterly which got removed eventually: https://t.co/ALFVQC0DDF
@AtkinsonAuberon @kestontnt Indeed. @kestontnt, is this the piece you referred to? Not sure how you could mix up my name with that guy's, but a mistake is easily made. https://t.co/G82gUjLdh8
This is a strange description of what happened, as per the journal itself: https://t.co/kR82A4zU77
RT @Whtapl: @GrayzoneProject @MaxBlumenthal @MarkAmesExiled And what the hell is wrong with Portland State these days? I don’t remember it…
@GrayzoneProject @MaxBlumenthal @MarkAmesExiled And what the hell is wrong with Portland State these days? I don’t remember it being like that when I lived there https://t.co/itT2Ez7hLG
@RealPeerReview Wow straight beneath it: opinion essay At least.. before some death threats made it go away. https://t.co/cVxyHgmzvN
このプロフィールでこれはすごい。 https://t.co/Kx1FXUFV06 "理観の無い人、歴史修正主義者、レイシスト、セクシストその他差別主義者を罵倒します"
RT @emigrl: 「植民地主義擁護論」 https://t.co/tT8bOFHfD5 すごいなこれ… 過去の植民地主義を評価するだけでなく、今うまくいってない旧被植民地の問題解決に植民地主義の再導入すべきって話になってる。
RT @tgiovanetti: Freaking unbelievable: Academic journal has to withdraw from publication a peer-reviewed article because of threats of per…
Freaking unbelievable: Academic journal has to withdraw from publication a peer-reviewed article because of threats of personal violence to the journal editor. We are losing civilization, people. https://t.co/Sc9rmglyat
@ProfDaveAndress Didn’t work for Bruce Gilley. Article retracted due to “serious and credible threats of personal violence” against the editors of the journal he published in. https://t.co/07Ki5w9tER
Me es muy difícil asumir que en el año 2018 sigamos teniendo un debate en España sobre si colonización o colonialismo son fenómenos/ideologías de los que vanagloriarse. Revista académica tuvo que retirar un artículo en defensa del colonialismo https://t.co
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
There's no floor to western cultural deterioration...
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
@Steve_Sailer @hbdchick @JayMan471 @gcochran99 @razibkhan @HarmlessYardDog
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
RT @KirkegaardEmil: Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://…
Literally threatening academics with violence because they wrote an essay you don't like. How low can you go? https://t.co/QsncpUh9qJ https://t.co/U67nv7ag25
@DemandRights The editor requested withdrawal. T&F, however, put up a strange statement that allows them to wiggle out of the situation by referring to threats of violence. I'm sure the threats were real, but they should have put up a stronger statem
RT @EricRoyalLybeck: @GEdwardsTwit @toadmeister Publishing is a means to an end: having a discussion. I mean this BS was published: https…
@GEdwardsTwit @toadmeister Publishing is a means to an end: having a discussion. I mean this BS was published: https://t.co/iAWKHoDWUl Doesn't make it 'true'
The case for colonialism Article de Bruce Gilley censuré @amnestypresse @EU_Humanists @IHEU @article19org @LDH_Fr @EmmanuelPierrat @PenFrancais https://t.co/rXQ6B5akZ9 https://t.co/BtzBj6XQdz
@mjauhola Viittaamme kirjoituksessa ainoastaan siihen, mitä lehden verkkosivuilla lukee poisvetämisen yhteydessä, emme itse prosessiin julkaisemisen taustalla: https://t.co/JRt9Vsa06C
@pdkmitchell We won't agree on the main point so let me just clarify the smaller stuff: 1- The main reason for retraction of Gilley's paper was "credible threats of personal violence". Not sure why you doubt it, since this seems a perfectly reasonable tac
#LitPick #Kolonialismus als feine Sache - endlich gefunden und dann das https://t.co/pokkV3z0sE #Wissenschaftleruntersich https://t.co/TPPHh1eyS6
@MaxBlumenthal @ggreenwald Remember that article on colonialism that came out of Portland State? https://t.co/itT2Ez7hLG
Yes, I’m familiar with T&F’s statement, which does not actually stipulate what the *outcome* of the peer review was. I recommend you read the statements made by the editorial board of the journal itself. https://t.co/CWJo5FI4ZE https://t.co/fTCyQjLMN
@DrNatOsborne Hi Natalie! Late response here, but NAS will not be publishing unreviewed articles. We'd recommend you read T&F's statement on the article's withdraw and notice that it actually passed the double blind peer review, which is why it was pub
Prof Gilleys and Nigel Biggar s articles seem to make sense to me. https://t.co/Chl53DRZEk
@tandfonline You utter cowards succumbing to a few screeching leftists and withdrawing the peer-reviewed article. I guess the truth hurts some so much they have to ban it. https://t.co/sxrs5QRkps
RT @Daenerys8888: @tandfonline Research article, having been through the peer review process, is withdrawn because the Left are cowards and…
@tandfonline Research article, having been through the peer review process, is withdrawn because the Left are cowards and can't handle the truth, so instead it bans it. https://t.co/sxrs5QRkps https://t.co/ChTYcw4I2S
INTERESTING or ABSURD THOUGHTS...? SHOULD ZAMBIA BE RE-COLONISED…??? Follow these thoughts, if you can… [although I hear this article has been withdrawn by the publisher, Third World Quarterly] The questions are: Shouldn’t... https://t.co/uehHjdV1vi
RT @AfricanWriters: Idiots abound in the world! https://t.co/cJ6XIR7MKP
@NationTalk Bruce Gilley (2017) The case for colonialism, Third World Quarterly https://t.co/npMbfs409d
Bruce Gilley (2017) The case for colonialism, Third World Quarterly, Taylor & Francis https://t.co/npMbfs409d
@aaronjmate @MazMHussain @leahmcelrath @areidross @SPLC Reminds me of https://t.co/KTHM127gyJ
RT @h7n33n: @karenhunter Last year, Third World Quarterly published "The Case for Colonialism," which found "Western colonialism was, as a…
@karenhunter Last year, Third World Quarterly published "The Case for Colonialism," which found "Western colonialism was, as a general rule, both objectively beneficial and subjectively legitimate" PDF: https://t.co/zN6TkeGKKE It was withdrawn owing to dea
This made me surprised. How it is difficult to talk in support of Colonialism in the developed west. The article was twice investigated and approved, but the journal editor has subsequently received serious and credible threats of personal violence. https
This has got to be the most elaborate troll i've seen in a while 'The Case for colonialism' https://t.co/TwLv1dUi9p https://t.co/Gd1A1uU71y
What's going on within the academe nowadays? Can anyone among the academic folk let us know? The publisher... https://t.co/8S14y0xDCz
Whoever it is who @thirdworldq allowed this distasteful article get published must be held to account (The case for colonialism) https://t.co/CTr9EnIwmO
@Solin_2022 The link to the original of where the article is supposed to be but read what is in its place. https://t.co/hfS23TIwGA
@Marjoleinvpagee @EsoClose @constanteyn Artikel teruggetrokken wegens 'serious and credible threats of personal violence': "The case for colonialism", by #BruceGilley, https://t.co/wkaPk8V2dL Retract or rebut? 'Controversy over a paper in favor of #colonia
Academics eh? "This Viewpoint essay has been withdrawn at the request of the academic journal editor...the journal editor has subsequently received serious & credible threats of personal violence. These threats are linked to the publication of this ess
RT @skommana1: Never heard of"Third World Quarterly"but how did I miss this? https://t.co/B5qWHVNrs0 "Scholarly"piece argues COLONIALISM wa…
Deserves sober consideration. Some of this coincides with the end of The Politics of Virtue -- especially the advocacy of more substantial 'social' trather than 'liberal' intervention by Western countries. But tension between paternalism and capitalist exp
The case for colonialism https://t.co/eKRYzgWFQM
Wow... https://t.co/kAMc7NZrRL
Whoa. I've not seen a peer-reviewed paper withdrawn by a publisher for this reason » The case for colonialism https://t.co/ez5J2JJlaf
@matthewasears Their reason for removing the article...no admission of flaws but because of "serious & credible threats of personal violence." Total cop-out. https://t.co/Jlcl9rmc7S
RT @CliffordAsness: Yes #resistance Trump is the only threat to free speech out there. Presidents come and go, thankfully, but our universi…
RT @CliffordAsness: Yes #resistance Trump is the only threat to free speech out there. Presidents come and go, thankfully, but our universi…
RT @CliffordAsness: Yes #resistance Trump is the only threat to free speech out there. Presidents come and go, thankfully, but our universi…