Peer 1
The authors' admission of a sampling problem for the lightness claims (of course the fundamental problem goes far deeper than this) doesn't go far enough...
PubPeer
Peer 1
Here is an interesting and revealing series of statements: "...vision cannot rely on entire images...the extraordinary detail in most retinal images will rarely, if ever, activate the full array of…
Peer 1
A fourth iteration of this paper is the PNAS article "How biological vision succeeds in the physical world" (Purves, Monson, Sundarajan, Wojtach, 2014)...
Peer 1
Why they're the same: The titles are obviously nearly identical. The claims are the same. First, we are told that visual percepts do not correspond to the properties of the physical world, and that…