RT @GorinMoti: @jessesingal Good illustration: take the famous arthroscopic surgery study. It found no difference in patient satisfaction b…
Nonsense. Idiotic illustration. With gender surgery (a) body shaping can't be faked & (b) *patient satisfaction is the goal*. The sole symptom trans folk have is *discomfort with body shape.* Surgery & hormones produce the body shape that provides
RT @GorinMoti: @jessesingal Good illustration: take the famous arthroscopic surgery study. It found no difference in patient satisfaction b…
RT @GorinMoti: @jessesingal Good illustration: take the famous arthroscopic surgery study. It found no difference in patient satisfaction b…
@jessesingal Good illustration: take the famous arthroscopic surgery study. It found no difference in patient satisfaction between sham surgery and real. If all that matters is satisfaction, then it would be clinically justified to expose patients to surgi
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
@Freire1Pb At either price @CBCNews, best to pay for procedures which actually work https://t.co/yJWrwWfnWN
for example,knees... https://t.co/kpGNMwxxrY.... or shoulders.... https://t.co/R33995u4Sh.... or folks that do just fine without their ACL https://t.co/mK43tn6zkb(no, you don't always need your ACL).. again not all ppl need their acl https://t.co/guuIGcZ8j
RT @93MGomes: Surgery: The ultimate placebo
RT @WithRespectPT: @guiterfisio Mas razón que un santo 👇🏼 https://t.co/Mk0GjtIyPV Hay más en esta línea pero baste saber que los efectos…
RT @AsgeirJakola: @VPrasadMDMPH @VPrasadMDMPH great on sham procedures, using ORBITA as example. Here are a few other mind-blowing and pote…
RT @AsgeirJakola: @VPrasadMDMPH @VPrasadMDMPH great on sham procedures, using ORBITA as example. Here are a few other mind-blowing and pote…
@VPrasadMDMPH @VPrasadMDMPH great on sham procedures, using ORBITA as example. Here are a few other mind-blowing and potential practice-changing sham studies: https://t.co/F8cQ2W65u8 AND https://t.co/oRPgtJPlYw AND follow-up https://t.co/o9xhxnS04X. Do you
@VPrasadMDMPH As long as the patients are fully informed of the risks of the sham surgery before they agree to sign on. (I wouldn't sign up.) Here's an RCT with a sham control involving knee surgery that revealed the sham surgery was just as 'successful.'
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
@guiterfisio Mas razón que un santo 👇🏼 https://t.co/Mk0GjtIyPV Hay más en esta línea pero baste saber que los efectos placebo y halo son muy poderosos, sobre todo cuando hay miedo y dolor de por medio.
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
Cirurgia placebo. Bom domingo.
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
Meniscectomia parcial artroscópica versus cirurgia simulada para ruptura degenerativa do menisco | NEJM https://t.co/HoDX0uTIyq
Surgery: The ultimate placebo
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
RT @lcos3060: Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia…
Pensa em estudo que é puro ouro... O estudo é de uma qualidade que beira a perfeição. O procedimento cirúrgico em ortopedia mais utilizado no planeta é um placebo. https://t.co/Ekh1JKU7As
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica parcial no es superior a la operación placebo en la rotura degenerativa parcial de menisco.…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica parcial no es superior a la operación placebo en la rotura degenerativa parcial de menisco.…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica parcial no es superior a la operación placebo en la rotura degenerativa parcial de menisco.…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica parcial no es superior a la operación placebo en la rotura degenerativa parcial de menisco.…
La meniscectomía artroscópica parcial no es superior a la operación placebo en la rotura degenerativa parcial de menisco. Los pacientes mejoran en ambos casos, pero quizás no mejoran por lo que creemos que mejoran. https://t.co/MjUfWRNR1j
@stratodoc22 Thank you. This kind of paper would be impossible to get published in the high impact journals if it was drug-related. A "placebo knee operation" proved to be better than the most commonly performed knee operation. https://t.co/yoyIKhhdS2 ht
RT @jt_kerwin: A lot of medical trials seem incredibly underpowered to me. This knee surgery vs. placebo surgery paper is a cool idea, but…
A lot of medical trials seem incredibly underpowered to me. This knee surgery vs. placebo surgery paper is a cool idea, but they were powered for about a 50% effect size and actually saw effects of about 10%. https://t.co/i2WnjtooYt
@cauwelaert Outcome na meniscusresectie bij 35+ in vergelijking met placebo controle Tip: Resultaten zijn “identiek” https://t.co/icdyrHvtIy https://t.co/g8GUFMtAZk
@KaoutarOulichki @MichalLaurent11 De wetenschappelijke evidentie is al opkomende sinds 2013. Riziv probeert reeds sinds 2019 om met advies. Nu blijkbaar dwingender. https://t.co/JBHBv5CFR4 https://t.co/icdyrHvtIy
@KaoutarOulichki Een ingreep die niet werkt is ook de oplossing niet hé... https://t.co/AtA1kNZDGq
@VanDammeEDU Er is echt wel evidentie om bepaalde ingrepen. Zoals bv. partiële meniscectomie, boven een bepaalde leeftijd. Niet te zomaar doen. Het gaat hier echt wel over appropriate care, die internationaal als best practice wordt aanzien en geen random
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica no fue superior a la operación placebo en pacientes con rotura degenerativa de menisco. Los…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica no fue superior a la operación placebo en pacientes con rotura degenerativa de menisco. Los…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica no fue superior a la operación placebo en pacientes con rotura degenerativa de menisco. Los…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica no fue superior a la operación placebo en pacientes con rotura degenerativa de menisco. Los…
RT @guiterfisio: La meniscectomía artroscópica no fue superior a la operación placebo en pacientes con rotura degenerativa de menisco. Los…
La meniscectomía artroscópica no fue superior a la operación placebo en pacientes con rotura degenerativa de menisco. Los pacientes tenían niveles similares de dolor y funcionalidad a los 12 meses de la intervención en ambos grupos. [https://t.co/CPyI7y
RT @painphysio: “In this trial involving patients without knee osteoarthritis but with symptoms of a degenerative medial meniscus tear, the…
RT @painphysio: “In this trial involving patients without knee osteoarthritis but with symptoms of a degenerative medial meniscus tear, the…
RT @painphysio: “In this trial involving patients without knee osteoarthritis but with symptoms of a degenerative medial meniscus tear, the…
“In this trial involving patients without knee osteoarthritis but with symptoms of a degenerative medial meniscus tear, the outcomes after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy were no better than those after a sham surgical procedure” https://t.co/hsIWmyC07y
Big paper Thursday: In a RCT of 146 patients without knee osteoarthritis but with symptoms of a degenerative medial meniscus tear, the outcomes after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy were no better than those after a sham surgical procedure. https://t.co/
@kaulcsmc @jspertus @arnoldgehrke @hvanspall @djc795 @ATSandhu @dr_benoy_n_shah @drjohnm @FabienPraz @ThomPilgrim @BashirAlaour @drandrewsharp @iamritu @AugustinCoisne @JGrapsa @MadalinaGarbi @Umair2017 @SachinGoelMD I know ortho doesn't count (sorry @bone
@Achieve_xl @CMichaelGibson ORBITA was a well-done example for stenting; similar approach for any intervascular device. Sham meniscal tear repair: https://t.co/n0e7Ov0Ugh
@DrSyedHaider @andrewmoe The placebo effect is a genuine phenomenon. It clearly indicates that the human body has enormous potential for self-healing. If we can discover how to tap into it on demand, it will be one of the most significant discoveries in
@DaveyDom @fakemedecine Sinon y'a des réfs là qui sont bien plus pertinente que la durée de vie d'une prothèse https://t.co/B4fyqePovC
RT @thinkin_mkdeabh: @Scintigraphiste @GeekNfit @fakemedecine Oh y'en a pas mal qui cherchent à évaluer les effets d'une chirurgie vs place…
@Scintigraphiste @GeekNfit @fakemedecine Oh y'en a pas mal qui cherchent à évaluer les effets d'une chirurgie vs placebo et en général ça produit pas de résultats. Exemple : https://t.co/DbibRUWfVH https://t.co/f9lZcUdGMt https://t.co/Ozd8PETrzN https:/
RT @BrianRoemmele: “Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear”—NEJM The Sham Surgery or Place…
RT @BrianRoemmele: “Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear”—NEJM The Sham Surgery or Place…
RT @BrianRoemmele: “Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear”—NEJM The Sham Surgery or Place…
“Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear”—NEJM The Sham Surgery or Placebo Effect surgery well documented and quite repeatable in a predictive model it is well studied. Most just do not know about it. https:
@jen_aradia @Mifield @christapeterso Yes, and for surgeries where the patient is awake they have to fake the entire surgery. https://t.co/0QqKm3YKYF
変性半月板損傷に対する関節鏡下半月板部分切除術と偽手術の比較 https://t.co/k3ni2ZFZg8 半月板の関節鏡手術は🇺🇸で最も一般的な整形外科手術 フィンランド🇫🇮で実施された 変性半月板損傷の関節鏡下膝手術は「偽手術」より効果がないことが判明 *結構、大変な手術 術後も膝が不自由だし
@SkipFleshman @bijans At least for degenerative meniscal tears, I think there have been some solid RCTs (vs. sham surgery, for example) finding no benefit going back some years. Ex: https://t.co/C06DMLYYEx
@drjohnm I think you need some surgical placebos in the list, so I am going for: https://t.co/bjbr6HvnZt (because it is a classic and has powerful patient quotes) and FIDELITY for methods (blinding the writing committee): https://t.co/EifMhzwpWs
RT @shamteppo: @adamcifu Our #FIDELITY trial also mentioned in the article: https://t.co/APC9vvNskP https://t.co/G5EzPo34mJ
RT @shamteppo: @adamcifu Our #FIDELITY trial also mentioned in the article: https://t.co/APC9vvNskP https://t.co/G5EzPo34mJ
RT @shamteppo: @adamcifu Our #FIDELITY trial also mentioned in the article: https://t.co/APC9vvNskP https://t.co/G5EzPo34mJ
@adamcifu Our #FIDELITY trial also mentioned in the article: https://t.co/APC9vvNskP https://t.co/G5EzPo34mJ
@DrODWilliamson @YouTube No difference at 12 months Owen. https://t.co/wGhjSKaxwa And no difference at 2 years either. https://t.co/uTGcItwoa5 (Annals of Rheumatic Diseases). #ShamSurgeryFTW https://t.co/a8trd9Y3Ya
@JSagorro Yes but this is the reason for such a trial, it’s a common process 👇
So even in surgery v sham the patients are examined and picked prior to randomisation on who should respond to the active intervention? Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear https://t.co/RKgdppKQYg https:
@BobKlap Do your homework before surgery. In *some* cases, surgery is no better than placebo. https://t.co/1C5MYHWG4z
ついでに,以前衝撃を受けた, 患者も手術を受けたかどうかわからないRCT. 傷は同じ様にできている.#sham #外科 #手術 Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear | NEJM https://t.co/8XfGBAqssA
@BitcoinOhly @JamesMcDaniel So are all the people who respond to sham procedures insane? https://t.co/cKukKE0s5q
@WFKARS Perfect example of why we have different types of trials for reality's sake! Double-blind trial of masking! Hand washing! Distancing! That being said, the orthopods that chose to do the sham knee surgery study are evidence GODS in my book https
@BLobitz Is this the study you’re referencing? https://t.co/OTdMZFU8Fo
@idrissaberkane Sachant que cela a toujours un petit effet.. https://t.co/D7Rega8Nq6 https://t.co/xG1BMsUpOL Chirurgie ou pas même effets... https://t.co/u5LlNMwRJa
@JeanJac05197764 @Dcarreau12 Petit exemple : https://t.co/JqTZgOmoXh En gros opération du ménisque sur 146 patients. 70 opérés réellement / 76 mise en scène mais PAS OPERES. Résultat : au bout d'un an....aucune différence sur la "récupération" des genoux
Tässä linkki varsinaiseen tutkimukseen: https://t.co/APC9vvNskP
@benigma2017 Don't go running for the surgeon just yet, my friend--ICYMI, 'sham' surgery is just as effective (in some cases, more so) than 'regular' procedures to fix certain meniscus problems. Placebos rule. 💪 https://t.co/a1HTGiDGhN https://t.co/X4ZROe
RT @BJSM_BMJ: Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear | NEJM https://t.co/eN72VuEHW5
RT @BJSM_BMJ: Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear | NEJM https://t.co/eN72VuEHW5
Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear | NEJM https://t.co/eN72VuEHW5
RT @BJSM_BMJ: Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear: 2013 classic. Sihvonen et al. https:…
RT @BJSM_BMJ: Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear: 2013 classic. Sihvonen et al. https:…
“In this trial involving patients without knee osteoarthritis but with symptoms of a degenerative medial meniscus tear, the outcomes after arthroscopic partial meniscectomy were no better than those after a sham surgical procedure.”
RT @BJSM_BMJ: Arthroscopic Partial Meniscectomy versus Sham Surgery for a Degenerative Meniscal Tear: 2013 classic. Sihvonen et al. https:…