Zen Faulkes
Here's my stab at trying to show different flavours of peer review: http://neurodojo.blogspot.com/2014/04/the-varieties-of-peer-review...
Here's my stab at trying to show different flavours of peer review: http://neurodojo.blogspot.com/2014/04/the-varieties-of-peer-review...
Let me apologize for my inability to show complexity in this graph. There is so much smear that I hesitated trying to make the graph at all. The graph is meant as a starting point, not a final word…
I don't follow why the points above 0 on the y-axis are distinct (except for citations). The timing and rigour are all very similar.
Nice review of the current state of post-publication peer review.One comment regarding this passage:Many like the idea of central repositories and would love to see all comments about a paper…