Peer 3
In this specific case I woud rather suggest contacting the EIC of the journal as there is not too much to discuss.
In this specific case I woud rather suggest contacting the EIC of the journal as there is not too much to discuss.
Did you email the corresponding author with your concerns? (They're under no obligation to reply, of course). Don't assume that everyone assiduously checks PubPeer!
Can the authors please respond its been 5 months?
Agreed, Figure 5D has bands that look very similar, figure seems manipulated. Can the authors please provide the original raw blots uncropped blots ?